As a former insurance company defense lawyer, Michael knows how insurance companies think & act when evaluating injury claims. Let us use our inside knowledge to help you achieve maximum recovery.
Membership is limited to fewer than one percent (1%) of the nation’s lawyers, and is based on peer reviews.
Relationships With Our Local Judges
Mr. Fenimore was raised in Pensacola, and has the much needed relationships and respect of our local courtroom judges.
Millions of Dollars Recovered For Clients
Since 2011, we have recovered millions of dollars for our clients in resulting from the negligence of others.
Never a Fee, Unless We Win Your Case
We assume all the risk when you choose us to represent you. You will never pay us anything unless we win your case.
Pensacola Personal Injury Lawyer
Proudly Fighting For Pensacola Injury Victims Since 2011
At Michael E. Fenimore, P.A., we focus solely on personal injury cases. Our expertise covers a wide range of areas, including auto accidents, trucking accidents, motorcycle accidents, slip and fall incidents, wrongful death, brain injuries, medical malpractice, nursing home neglect, product defects, and more.
Our firm recognizes that experiencing a personal injury can significantly impact an individual’s quality of life and alter their entire future.
The legal complexities surrounding these situations often add extra stress and anxiety for accident victims. As your legal representative, we will vigorously advocate for you, ensuring that your experience with the legal process is professionally streamlined and free from unnecessary stress.
In challenging times like these, you need reliable legal counsel and representation. Acting quickly is crucial.
Insurance companies often try to quickly offer low settlements to resolve your claim, knowing that your medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering will continue to increase. They are trained to minimize their liability and settle for the smallest amount possible before you fully understand the extent of your damages. This is why it's crucial to hire Michael Fenimore, an experienced personal injury attorney who can work to secure a significantly better settlement than you might receive without legal representation. We provide an honest and transparent assessment of your case, informing you of potential challenges and helping you make an informed decision about how to proceed with your accident lawsuit.
"I hired Mr. Fenimore to represent me after I was involved in a car accident. He explained the process in a way I could completely understand. He worked diligently on my claim, guided me through the process, kept me updated on my case, and made me feel at ease. I highly recommend Michael..."
Jonah
Far exceeded my expectations
"Mr. Fenimore kept me informed and got me a result that far exceeded my expectations. Mr. Fenimore is a very personable attorney and he genuinely cares about his clients. I can’t begin to thank him enough for his time and attention to my case. I wholeheartedly recommend him and his team!"
Jacky
High level of legal and professional competence.
"He has always provided personal attention and handled my legal matters in a timely manner with outstanding results. I can attest to his high level of legal and professional competence. I give him my highest recommendation."
Jon
You Want Mr. Fenimore in Your Corner
"If you want an attorney who will take the time to explain things and walk you through the process, and not to mention get you a fantastic result (more than I ever thought possible), then you want Mr. Fenimore in your corner! There is no other attorney I would recommend!"
Diana
Made the Legal Process Easy
"Michael represented me in a motor vehicle accident. I was hospitalized and my vehicle was totaled. He made sure my expenses were completely covered and made the legal process as easy as I could’ve asked for. Highly recommend..."
C. Grace
Handled My Case Masterfully
"Mr. Fenimore handled my case masterfully. He worked diligently and efficiently to ensure my family’s interests were protected and more importantly displayed genuine concern for our needs throughout the entire process. I give him my highest recommendation."
Since founding his own practice in 2011, Michael E. Fenimore has dedicated his career to representing individuals who have suffered serious injuries in car accidents, slip and falls, defective product cases, and other personal injury matters. His background in insurance defense gives him a unique advantage when negotiating and litigating against insurance companies on behalf of injury victims.
"Getting our clients the full compensation for their injuries is my top priority."
Mr. Fenimore is widely recognized as one of Northwest Florida’s most tenacious and effective personal injury attorneys. He graduated with honors from the University of Florida and earned his Juris Doctor from Saint Louis University School of Law, where he was named a Dean’s Scholar. He is a proud member of the Top American Lawyers, and his case results include millions recovered for injured clients throughout the region. He is admitted to practice in Florida and Missouri, and holds memberships in the American Bar Association, The Florida Bar, The Missouri Bar, and the Florida Justice Association as an Eagle Member.
Getting our clients the full compensation for their injuries is our top priority. See some of our results below.
Auto Accident
Client was seriously injured in a rear-end car accident collision which necessitated shoulder surgery and multiple injective procedures in his neck and back.
$350k
OSHA Violations
Client who sustained catastrophic injuries which rendered him a complete paraplegic after falling from the roof of a home he was repairing.
$300k
Food-Related Injury
Case against a fast food restaurant where Plaintiff ingested numerous pieces of glass in his hamburger that the restaurant served him.
$475k
Auto Accident
At-fault driver suddenly and negligently made a right hand turn directly into the path of Mr. Fenimore’s clients, t-boning his clients’ vehicle at a high rate of speed.
$250k
Motorcycle Accident
Client was riding a motorcycle when the at-fault driver pulled out from an intersection directly in front of the client’s approaching motorcycle.
$160k
Auto Accident
Client was rear-ended at an estimated 40 mph which caused a severe whiplash injury resulting in nerve root impingement in her lumbar spine.
A small firm dedicated to giving each case our full attention
Why Choose Fenimore Injury Law
At Michael E. Fenimore, P.A., our Pensacola personal injury attorneys are committed to helping victims of negligence reclaim their lives. With decades of combined experience and deep roots in the community, we deliver highly personalized legal representation to every client we serve. We don’t treat cases like files — we treat them like families.
Our firm is built on a foundation of trial advocacy, negotiation skills, and compassion. We take the time to understand how your injury has impacted your day-to-day life, so we can present your story powerfully in front of a jury — or insurance adjuster. Whether your case involves a car accident, a slip and fall, a defective product, or a wrongful death claim, we are here to advocate for your recovery.
Our attorneys bring unique insight from prior experience in the insurance defense industry, which allows us to anticipate insurer tactics and build stronger, more strategic cases for our clients.
We Work on a Contingency Fee Basis
You don’t have to worry about upfront legal fees. We offer free consultations and only get paid if we recover compensation for you. It’s that simple.
Compassionate Representation with Proven Results
With millions recovered for injured clients throughout Northwest Florida, we have a strong record of success. But it’s the relationships we build — and the peace of mind we provide — that clients value most.
Resources for Personal Injury Victims in Pensacola, Florida
Types of Personal Injury Compensation You May Be Eligible For
Victims of serious accidents in Pensacola may be entitled to compensation for both financial and non-financial damages. These include medical expenses, lost income, future care costs, and pain and suffering. If your injury results in permanent disability or emotional trauma, your claim’s value may increase significantly.
Additional damages may include loss of earning capacity, rehabilitation costs, and, in cases involving married victims, loss of consortium for the spouse. Every case is unique, and our team will carefully evaluate your circumstances to ensure all potential damages are considered.
How the Value of Your Personal Injury Claim Is Calculated
Determining the value of a personal injury claim involves examining several factors, such as the extent of your injuries, their long-term impact, and the clarity of liability. Some key considerations include:
Severity and permanence of your injuries
Need for long-term medical care or assistive devices
Duration of recovery and time away from work
Degree of pain, suffering, or mental anguish
Loss of enjoyment of life or ability to participate in daily activities
Available insurance coverage and liability evidence
Insurance companies often attempt to undervalue claims. At Fenimore Injury Law, we work tirelessly to ensure your compensation reflects the full scope of your losses.
What to Do After a Serious Injury
Taking the right steps immediately after an injury can significantly affect the success of your personal injury claim. Here’s what we recommend:
Seek medical attention as soon as possible, even if injuries seem minor.
Document everything: photographs of injuries, accident scenes, damaged property, and anything else relevant.
Keep a record of medical appointments, treatments, and expenses.
Do not speak with the at-fault party’s insurance adjuster without legal representation.
Contact an experienced Pensacola personal injury attorney promptly to protect your rights.
Your actions in the hours and days after the incident can play a crucial role in the strength of your case. If you're unsure of what to do, reach out to our office—we’re here to guide you every step of the way.
Get Help from a Trusted Pensacola Personal Injury Lawyer
If you or a loved one has suffered a serious injury due to someone else’s negligence, contact Michael E. Fenimore, P.A. at (850) 434-6064 or fill out our online form to request a free, no-obligation consultation. We offer flexible appointment times and can travel to meet you if needed. There are no upfront fees—we only get paid if we recover compensation for you.
Frequently Asked Questions About Personal Injury Accidents in Pensacola
Look for a lawyer with proven experience, local knowledge, and a strong track record. Fenimore Injury Law, led by Michael E. Fenimore, offers personalized representation, decades of expertise, and a commitment to maximizing your compensation in Pensacola courts.
At Fenimore Injury Law, you pay nothing upfront. We work on a contingency fee basis, which means we only get paid if we win your case. This ensures you can access experienced legal representation without any financial risk. If there's no recovery, you owe us nothing.
In Florida, the statute of limitations for personal injury claims is typically two years from the injury date. A Pensacola personal injury attorney at Fenimore Injury Law can confirm deadlines and file promptly to protect your rights. Learn more here.
With experience defending insurance companies, I know their tactics to reduce payouts. At Fenimore Injury Law, we leverage this insight to counter their strategies, negotiate skillfully, and fight for the compensation you deserve. Learn more.
Compensation may include medical expenses, lost income, property damage, and emotional distress. Fenimore Injury Law’s experienced Pensacola personal injury attorneys negotiate aggressively to secure fair settlements for all damages.
Case timelines vary based on complexity, but most settle within months to a year. Fenimore Injury Law’s Pensacola personal injury attorneys work efficiently to resolve cases while ensuring no detail is overlooked.
Yes, Florida’s comparative negligence law allows recovery even if you’re partially at fault, though compensation may be reduced. Our Pensacola personal injury attorneys at Fenimore Injury Law assess fault and fight for your maximum award. Learn more here.
Seek medical care, document the scene, and avoid speaking to insurance adjusters. Then, consult a Pensacola personal injury attorney at Fenimore Injury Law for a free case review to understand your legal options. Learn more about the steps to take.
Fenimore Injury Law combines local expertise, personalized service, and a proven record of success. Attorney Michael E. Fenimore’s deep understanding of Pensacola’s legal landscape ensures clients receive trusted, results-driven representation.
Have more questions? Contact us for a free consultation with a trusted Pensacola personal injury lawyer.
